Rereadings, edited by Anne Fadiman -- BOOK REVIEW

 

Rereadings: Seventeen Writers Revisit Books They Love

BOOK REVIEW

I wanted to like this book more than I did. Anne Fadiman's collection of essays about books and reading, Ex Libris, was wonderful. Her book, The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down: A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors, and the Collision of Two Cultures, is some of the finest nonfiction writing I've ever encountered. I grabbed Rereadings off my shelf with those two experiences in mind. 

Only then did I catch the subtitle and realize that Fadiman didn't write the essays in this book. She is the editor of this collection of essays by 17 other writers. Specifically, these are essays originally published in a literary quarterly called The American Scholar, written on the theme of revisiting a book originally read prior to age 25. 

I was disappointed that Fadiman wasn't the author, but the premise still appealed to me. I'm a subscriber and big fan of Slightly Foxed, a literary journal dedicated to celebrating backlist books. The essays in Rereadings sounded like those I gobble up whenever a new issued of Slightly Foxed arrives. I didn't recognize any of the essay writers in Rereadings, but I don't recognize the essay writers in Slightly Foxed either, and that doesn't dampen my enthusiasm. 

What did dampen my enthusiasm -- and my spirits -- was the tone of most of the essays. In Slightly Foxed, people write about books they love and want you to read. Some are books they have reread many times, sometimes they only reread a book in order to write about it in Slightly Foxed. But they are excited to explain the joys of the book and encourage you to read it.  By the time I finish an issue of Slightly Foxed, my book wish list is noticeably longer. 

In Rereadings, most of the essays were about how a book the writer loved as a child, teen, or college student didn't stand up to reading again as an adult. Maybe the story seemed too simplistic when read with adult eyes, or the book hit wrong to current sensibilities, but for whatever reason, the magic was gone. Well, OK. But I'm an adult reading about these books now. I can't experience what it was like to read them as a teen ager so share their lessened appeal on rereading. Reading about why they are disappointing to an adult reader was a downer. I finished Rereadings with a list of books people no longer liked. 

That's not to say the essays were poorly written. They weren't. They were all polished and well-argued. But they didn't inspire me to read more, certainly not to reread. 

NOTE

Rereadings was one of the books from my TBR 26 in '26 list. I'm glad the challenge got me to finally read this one, but I won't be rereading it, that's for sure!